The Sunday nighttime 9 p.m. slot connected HBO is 1 of nan astir coveted spots connected television. This timeframe is wherever HBO places its champion dramas. These shows usually garner precocious viewership and go awards play darlings, particularly astatine nan Emmys. The Sopranos, Game of Thrones, Succession, House of nan Dragon, The White Lotus, and The Last of Us aired successful nan prestigious 9 p.m. hour. When The Idol received nan 9 p.m. slot successful June 2023, HBO fundamentally said, “This is important, and you request to watch it.” Yet, HBO learned a valuable lesson: location are nary guarantees successful life, moreover successful nan Sunday nighttime 9 p.m. slot.
Nearly 1 cardinal group tuned successful for nan first episode of The Idol. By nan end of nan five-episode first season, galore viewers, including myself, decided that was capable Tedros for 1 lifetime. HBO agreed and canceled nan series. Declining ratings and precocious costs were immoderate of nan reasons down nan cancellation. However, nan antagonistic reception from critics and audiences apt sealed nan show’s fate. Much of nan disapproval astir The Idol was warranted, pinch immoderate calling it nan worst show of nan year. Others person said it’s one of nan astir arguable shows ever. My problems pinch nan show stemmed from nan puzzling imaginative decisions made by co-creators Sam Levinson and Abel Tesfaye, aka The Weeknd.
Good premise but unspeakable execution
The official logline of The Idol: “Jocelyn is simply a popular idol who resolves to reclaim her title arsenic nan sexiest popular prima successful nan United States aft her past circuit was canceled pursuing a tense breakdown. She originates a analyzable narration pinch Tedros, a self-help guru and nan caput of a modern cult.”
The first portion of that logline plays retired complete nan first half of nan aviator episode. Jocelyn, played by Lily-Rose Depp, is preparing to motorboat a comeback pinch a caller single, World Class Sinner. Jocelyn is seen practicing choreography for nan song, posing for nan album’s screen art, and talking to a Vanity Fair writer. Unbeknownst to her, Jocelyn’s squad – managers and publicists to explanation executives – are moving down nan scenes to travel up pinch a consequence to a schematic photograph of her that leaked connected nan Internet. Yet, nary 1 connected nan squad wants to show Jocelyn, truthful they dress everything is each correct contempt being successful harm control.
The first 30 minutes is nan champion agelong of TV successful The Idol. Watching a popular prima regain power of her life is an absorbing show. Seeing really a squad of managers and executives tin manipulate a susceptible customer is simply a bully premise. Depp plays Jocelyn pinch conviction, making her consciousness for illustration a legit popular star. Unfortunately, those are nan past bully moments successful The Idol because Tedro (Tesfaye) enters nan fray successful nan 2nd half of nan episode, and nan show shifts toward their narration for nan remainder of nan series. A show astir nan euphony manufacture should not revolve astir a narration betwixt a popular prima and a cult leader.
What Tesfaye was going for pinch his capacity of Tedros is unknown. Was Tesfaye successful connected nan joke? I don’t know, which is simply a problem. One minute, Tedros is playing this mysterious and acheronian fig who loves BDSM, and past astatine different moments, he’s pronouncing carte blanche arsenic “cartay blanshay” and acting for illustration an insecure buffoon. It’s a unusual capacity that leaves nan assemblage pinch much questions than answers.
The Idol was billed arsenic a prestige play that would go a lightning rod successful nationalist discourse. This show premiered astatine nan Cannes Film Festival, signaling that it was meant to beryllium taken seriously. Yet arsenic nan antagonistic reception poured in, Tesfaye started to alteration his tune, telling GQ that nan aggregate tones successful nan bid were purposefully added and that The Idol was “puppet-mastering” nan audience’s feelings done nan show. This felt for illustration a rotation area from Tesfaye, trying to prevention look and explicate nan baffling decisions down nan schematic activity scenes and satirical outlook connected nan euphony industry.
Creative overhaul and rocky accumulation led to its downfall
Amy Seimetz, nan creator down The Girlfriend Experience, signed connected to nonstop and executive produce The Idol. The Girlfriend Experience, a bid astir a rule student moving arsenic a high-end escort, received rave reviews for its depictions of sexuality and feminism, truthful bringing Seimetz to use those themes to The Idol made a ton of sense. Unfortunately, Seimetz exited nan bid successful April 2022. Levinson was brought successful to reshoot astir of nan bid owed to a “change successful imaginative directions.”
In March 2023, Rolling Stone reported astir a toxic group and really The Idol became “sexual torture porn.” The study stated that Seimetz vanished astir 80% of nan bid earlier exiting. Tesfaye allegedly believed nan show was heading excessively overmuch into a “female perspective.” With Seimetz out, The Idol would displacement attraction to nan emotion communicative betwixt Tedros and Jocelyn, pinch an summation successful schematic activity scenes and a alteration successful a female redemption arc. In consequence to nan report, Tesfaye tweeted a deleted scene from nan show that degraded Rolling Stone.
It’s difficult to conflict Rolling Stone erstwhile nan imaginative changes outlined in The Idol became meticulous crippled points. Putting 2 and 2 together, Seimetz astir apt wanted to attraction much connected Jocelyn’s independency and redemption than her narration pinch Tedros. Seimetz’s type of The Idol is nan show I wanted to watch. Unfortunately, that ne'er happened, nor will it ever happen. Once nan Rolling Stone article surfaced, The Idol could ne'er recover.
A fascinating failure
The Idol is simply a fascinating failure. I thin to respect creators who return large swings that are met pinch mixed results. In nan aforesaid GQ article mentioned above, Tesfaye highlighted Paul Verhoeven and Basic Instinct as references for The Idol. Verhoeven is simply a filmmaker celebrated for making thought-provoking creation that is some satirical and provocative.
Showgirls and Starship Troopers are 2 of Verhoeven’s films that initially did not activity but person been critically reevaluated and championed successful nan years pursuing their release. Only clip will show if The Idol develops a affirmative estimation successful nan future. However, I’m not betting connected it.
Stream The Idol connected Max. Don’t opportunity I didn’t pass you.
- 6 astir underrated TV shows of 2023
- 8 astir astonishing TV show cancellations of 2023
- Bodies is 1 of Netflix’s astir celebrated shows correct now. Here’s why you should watch it
- 10 astir arguable TV shows ever
- 2023’s champion sci-fi show is connected Apple TV+. Here’s why you should watch it correct now